đ„ This Week in Spain: And Then There Were 37
Also: Doxxing celebrities and those weird political banners.
By @IanMount and @AdrianBono | May 18, 2023 | Madrid | Issue #14
đ Welcome to The Tapa, an English-language, weekly newsletter about all things Spain!
đ„ This Week in a Nutshell: ETA terrorism is once again being debated only days before the election thanks to Bildu. Because the more things change, the more things stay the same.
đșIf you havenât subscribed yet, please do so by clicking on the button below.
𫶠And if you already have, please send this newsletter around to your friends and family and help us keep growing.
The gloves have come off
đ€Ź âLegal, But Not Decentâ
The decision by EH Bildu, a left-wing, Basque nationalist/separatist party, to run 44 convicted members and associates of the ETA terrorist groupâincluding seven convicted for murderâin the May 28 (28M) elections did not sit well with, well, anyone.Â
And it seriously hotted up the 28M campaign. EH Bildu has supported the razor-thin majority coalition led by socialist Prime Minister Pedro SĂĄnchez, and received backing for things it wanted in return, so SĂĄnchezâs right-wing opposition in the PP and Vox (and some politicians in his own party) immediately slammed Bildu and the PSOE leader.
PP boss Alberto NĂșñez FeijĂło said, "SĂĄnchez is a captive president of Bildu and is dragging down the entire nation,â while Madrid regional president Isabel DĂaz Ayuso and Vox leaders called for Bildu to be banned.
Even SĂĄnchezâs Interior Minister, Fernando Grande-Marlaska, said that including the ETA members caused âunjustified harm to the victims of terrorismâ, while the PSOE President of AragĂłn, Javier LambĂĄn, called for âbreaking off any relationship with Bildu.â
Heading back through the ETA history tunnel: Ostensibly set up to fight for an independent Basque country, ETAâs terrorists killed 829 people, according to a 2009 Spanish government document, including 486 members of the police and armed forces, and 343 civilians.Â
The dead included everyone from Luis Carrero Blanco, the expected heir to Franco who was killed in a 1973 car-bombing in Madrid (the explosion was so large it sent his car several floors in the air and into the courtyard of the monastery next door), to the 21 people, including a pregnant woman and two children, who were killed in the 1987 Hipercor supermarket bombing in Barcelona.Â
This brutal history has long made running ETA candidates unthinkable, for obvious reasons. In fact, in 2003 Spainâs Supreme Court banned the Batasuna political party for being a âcomplementâ of ETA, and to stop it amplifying and justifying the terrorist groupâs attacks. Several years later, the EUâs human rights court upheld the decision.
So what then hell were they thinking? Thatâs the tricky bit. EH Bildu leader Arnaldo Otegi was a local MP and spokesperson for Batasunaâand an ETA member who was convicted of participating in the 1979 kidnapping of the director of the MichelĂn plant in Vitoria, Luis Abaitua (and suspected of participating in three others).
The backlash against Bilduâand the PSOEâfrom ETA victims and the opposition was swift and tough. Speaking from Washington, where he met with President Joe Biden, SĂĄnchez himself weighed in to control the damage, calling the inclusion of the ETA candidates âlegal but not decentâ.
Behind the scenes, the PSOE expressed its, um, displeasure to Bildu, and leaned on the Basque party to do something to take off the heat. But the PSOE canât afford to totally break ties with Bilduâas it will likely need the partyâs support if it has any chance to stay in power after national elections later this year.
The other big problem for the PSOEâbeyond Bilduâs gambit being a terrible look and morally dodgyâwas that the move played into the PPâs desire to make the campaign about the PSOEâs suitability and choice of allies and made it much harder for the socialists to emphasize their achievements over the last few years, from new labor laws to the recovery from the pandemic.
The pushback workedâto a point. The seven EH Bildu candidates who had been convicted of being involved in murders announced they would not take up seats if elected, a move that calmed the watersâto a pointâbut also sent the opposition pushing for more (along the line of FeijĂłoâs â7 down, 37 to goâ). For her part, the PSOEâs spokeswoman, Territorial Policy Minister Isabel RodrĂguez, acknowledged that the 37 left were still a problem: âThere are still many steps to take,â she said. You can almost hear her sigh.
SĂĄnchezâs two face-to-face debates with the opposition since the Bildu incident devolved into pissing matches where FeijĂło said SĂĄnchez was âmore generous with the hangman than the victimsâ and noted he had vowed multiple times in the past to never make deals with Bildu, and SĂĄnchez responding that the PP was living in the past and when it had nothing to offer it just said âETA, ETA, ETA.â Inspiring stuff! (Not.)
Ultimately, while the distraction could offer the PP a national poll bump among those who donât totally trust SĂĄnchezâs PSOE, it is unlikely to lead to a massive vote swing in regional and municipal elections where, as the phrase goes, âAll politics is local.â And it wonât lead to the banning of EH Bildu: ETA ceased its terrorist activities 12 years ago and has since disbanded, and even victims groups call the party âlegal.â
đ A Message From Our Sponsor
Bucólico Café is a project of connection that was born as a specialty coffee shop.
We value time and understand that it represents both a cycle and an instantâchronology and nostalgia. BucĂłlico is a space that connects oneâs soul with the purity, lightness and beauty of the countrysideâwhile being in the city. Via a cup of coffee, a piece of cake or a songâŠ
Located on Calle de Barbieri 4 â a few blocks from Plaza Chueca â BucĂłlico reassures the soul with a feeling of home.
Follow Bucólico Café on Instagram.
đŹ Five things to discuss at dinner parties this week:
1. âForget it, Ana Rosa. Itâs Chinatown.â
You probably already know who Ana Rosa Quintana is if you watch Spanish TVâs morning shows. And as we mentioned last week, the journalist and undisputed queen of morning television is set to take over the afternoons as well, as she prepares to fill the content void left by the cancellation of trash TV talk show SĂĄlvame.
Never a stranger to controversy, Quintana was trending on social media early this week after making what was perceived by many to be a classist/racist comment against the Chinese community.
During the San Isidro festivities this weekend, Mayor JosĂ© Luis MartĂnez-Almeida awarded the Madrid Medal of Honor to several celebrities and personalities. Quintana was among them, and as she went on stage to receive the medal celebrating her professional career, she started talking about how much she loves Madrid.
First it was the generic platitudes everyone uses. She said she was âhappy and movedâ to be there, adding that the fact that this was happening in the city where she was born âfilled her with happiness.â
âMadrid is the land where thousands of Spaniards come to make a living. Madrid is all of Spain,â she said.
When describing her early childhood and humble beginnings, Quintana then decided to mention the neighborhood in Southern Madrid where she grew up. Thatâs when it went to hell.
âI grew up in Usera, a working-class neighborhood of hard-working people, before it became Chinatown,â she said. Her comment lit up Twitter like a phosphorus grenade, as thousands took to accuse her of racism and classism and of offending the Chinese community in Usera, the district with the highest concentration of Chinese citizens in all of Spain.
Quintana has been in hot water before, after making insensitive comments about the Black and Roma communities.
And this wasnât even the first time Quintana made controversial comments about the Chinese community. Back in 2020, at the height of the COVID-19 pandemic, she accused Chinese people of âbringing us the virusâ.
The outrage came from people who seemed to interpret her contrast between Usera as a neighborhood of working people and Usera as Chinatown as a dig against the Chinese population there. (It bears mentioning that calling Usera Chinatown is hard to call racist in itselfâMadridâs official tourism agency website literally promotes Usera as âMadridâs Chinatownâ and invites visitors to participate in the Chinese New Year festivities and try âthe best Chinese foodâ in the city.)
Thousands of people have signed a petition on change.org to take her medal away for making a âracist, xenophobicâ speech during the ceremony.
Thereâs even been a Twitter feud between Podemosâs mayoral candidate in Madrid Roberto Sotomayor and current deputy mayor Begoña VillacĂs (Ciudadanos). When Sotomayor said that, if elected, his first order would be to get that medal back, VillacĂs simply tweeted back: âYou wonât take any City Hall medal back because youâre no one to do so.â
You thought SĂĄlvame leaving our TVs would mean less drama? Think again.
2.đ§âđ Job growth has a accent and a gender
Â
You might have noticed that Spain has seen a job boom recently. At the end of the first quarter of 2023, the INE national statistics institute reported that there were 20.45m employed workers in Spain, up 368,000 from a year earlier and the highest first quarter number since 2008 when there was, you know, a housing bubble.
That job growth had a very specific makeupâand one that you might not have expected. Of the 368,000 new workers, 140,000 were foreign women (43.6% of the total) and 44,000 were women with double-nationality (which nationalized immigrants often have), El PaĂs reports.
If you add those numbers up, 55.6% of the new jobs created in the last year are held by women who have a non-Spanish passport. And then if you add in foreign menâanother 22.5%âover 78% of the job-holders have a non-Spanish passport.
So, why so many? Itâs not much of a surprise, really.Â
Spainâs population growth (as small as it is) has come through immigration. The population of Spanish passport holders has been stagnant for more than a decade, while the foreign population has grown regularly, save in the years right after the housing bubble, and now makes up about 12% of the population.Â
At the same time, many of the new jobs are in hospitality. In April, a month that admittedly was home to the hospitality boomlet that is Semana Santa, 52% of the new jobs were in hospitality. And, as Universidad Jaume I professor Vicente CastellĂł noted in a recent Cinco DĂas piece, these are generally the kind of low-paying positions that native job-seekers are less likely to accept in good economic times.
There are also specific reasons for a boom in foreign women workers right now. HipĂłlito SimĂłn, an economics professor at the Universidad de Alicante, told El PaĂs that inflation often pushes people into the labor market when their partnerâs salary canât keep up. And Spain has taken in more than 150,000 Ukrainian immigrants since Russiaâs invasionâ64% of them women.
3.đž Amber Heardâs been Madridoxxed
Amber Heard moved to Spain recently, first to Mallorca and then, several weeks ago, to Madrid, with her two-year-old daughter Oonagh Paige. The move was meant as an escape and restart a year after she lost the bitter defamation case filed by ex-husband Johnny Depp. âSheâs bilingual in Spanish and is happy there, raising her daughter away from all the noise,â a friend of Heardâs told the Daily Mail Online.
Some of the noise is back, however. Journos and fans have tracked her down to a house in the El Viso neighborhood (where Ava Gardner and Juan Domingo PerĂłn were once unhappy neighborsâshe hated the way he practiced his future Casa Rosada speeches from the balcony, he hated her parties).
The El Viso house is apparently 253m2 big, cost north of âŹ1.5m, and was totally renovated by Heard. Since itâs been located, a herd of journos and fans have staked out the door to ask for autographs and report on her StarsâThey're Just Like Us! activities (she receives her own Amazon packages!). She even gave a short interview to one.
Heard has been seen (and photographed) running in Retiro Park and visiting the Museo Sorolla. Through it all, she seems to have handled theâletâs be honestâsort of invasive coverage with grace, signing autographs and taking selfies with fans with a smile. She does indeed speak fluent Spanish, which she is said to have learned growing up in Texas.Â
The press coverage eventually got too intense for Heard, however. She reportedly called the PolicĂa Nacional, who in turn told the reporters to give Heard some space and not film the interior of the house.
4.đŠ Now, about those campaign bannersâŠ
With the elections 10 days away, candidates in Madrid are ready to try anything that will a) get them some more votes and b) get them more followers. And since center-right candidate and Madrid community president Isabel DĂaz Ayuso (PP) is marching towards election with a smile on her face (polls suggest sheâs really close to getting an absolute majority), the other candidates are, well, sorta desperate for attention.
And soâŠearly this week some unusual campaign banners appeared around Madrid with the very objective (hope springs eternal!) of going viral on social media, courtesy of far-left Podemos and center-left MĂĄs Madrid.
Podemosâs banner (see photo above) features their mayoral candidate, former athlete Roberto Sotomayor, and aggressively targets (not in a positive way) the residents in the upscale Madrid neighborhood of Salamanca:
âThis neighborhoodâs cayetanos have had a mayor who, for four years, has been dedicated exclusively to them. On May 28, that will change quicklyâ.
âCayetanoâ is a pejorative term used to describe posh people (like those living in Salamanca). The term comes from the fact that a lot of them are, indeed, named âCayetanoâ. And it was popularized a few years ago by rock band Carolina Durante, which penned a song whose lyrics explain what you need to own, how you need to dress and how you need to speak in order to sound like them.
Podemos has historically been critical of Spainâs one percenters, so itâs no surprise that itâs attacking them and PP mayor MartĂnez-Almeida directly. The far-left partyâs leaders have repeatedly attacked him and accused him of having a style of governing that only benefits a few.
People on Twitter (where else) have been divided over the message. In fact, another left-leaning candidate for mayor (and no fan of Almeida), Recupera Madridâs Luis Cueto, has criticized Sotomayorâs strategy to insult his potential voters.
The second, ahem, âunusualâ banner comes from center-left MĂĄs Madrid and indirectly attacks DĂaz Ayuso. The message is based on something Ayusoâs opponent MĂłnica GarcĂa has said and it simply reads âMadrid is the shitâ.
OK, fair. Translating âes la hostiaâ as âis the shitâ may not be entirely accurate. Itâs more like âMadrid is greatâ except⊠really great. Like, âIs the bomb!â (Literally, itâs âIs the communion waferâ, but anywayâŠ)
The quote comes directly from GarcĂa, who criticized DĂaz Ayuso for her political ambitions and for sometimes sounding like sheâs running for Prime Minister rather than President of the Madrid community. âMadrid is great,â GarcĂa said in an official party statement, adding: âWhoever wants to run to be in the Moncloa Palace should go to the Moncloa Palaceâ.
5.đ« Hear the one about the Vox Councilwoman selling cocaine?
Whoops! Considering how far-right Vox is supposed to be the party of law and order, this is definitely not good for the brand.
This week we found out that Ana GonzĂĄlez MartĂnez, a councilwoman at the Parla City Hall, in the Madrid community was, according to police, moonlighting as a cocaine dealer.
GonzĂĄlez MartĂnez, who was third on the candidates list this election, was arrested on Thursday by the National Police in a bust that was conducted in Southern Madrid and several towns in the Toledo region where she owned property.
Police say that during the raid they found over one kilo of cocaine, significant amounts of marijuana, short and long range weapons, cash and high end vehicles.
To make matters more awkward, GonzĂĄlez MartĂnez starred in a video with RocĂo Monasterio, Voxâs presidential contender in the Madrid community, denouncing the squatter problem in her district and saying that they were bringing âcrime and drugsâ.
According to local media, the councilwoman is being charged with drug trafficking, money laundering and electricity theft (police says she also had a significant marijuana plantation and was stealing electricity for the indoor cultivation of cannabis).
GonzĂĄlez MartĂnez has announced she has dropped out of the race after the leading Vox candidate in the Parla City Hall asker her to do so.
A statement released by Vox in the Madrid community said that âafter information published in various media outlets, VOX once again reiterates its commitment to its citizens and, given the legal situation the current councilwoman is involved in, has asked her to tender her resignation, to which miss Ana GonzĂĄlez voluntarily agreed.â
GonzĂĄlez MartĂnez is currently under arrest along with her husbandâwho is in the military.
And it gets better! In a report by El PaĂs, a person who was allegedly close to GonzĂĄlez MartĂnez claims she was nicknamed âthe naziâ. âShe was polite but very radical. She was against immigrants, against social programsâŠagainst everything.â
She must be fun at parties. đ„ł
đ Before you go, please remember to share this newsletter with your friends on social media. The more we grow, the more information weâll be able to offer each week.
Weâll be back next week with more.